Changes Announced to Plans for WTC Site

by Etta Sanders

Architect Daniel Libeskind, along with officials of the LMDC and Port Authority, presented a "refined" version of his master plan for the World Trade Center site on Sept. 17. The changes remove truck access and transportation infrastructure from the footprints, an aspect of the original plan that some victim's families fiercely opposed. The revised plan also moves more than 1 million square feet of office space to a new building south of Liberty Street and creates a new park between Liberty and Cedar Streets.
Architect Daniel Libeskind announces revisions to his master plan for the World Trade Center site. Photo by Allan Tannenbaum
The changes, Libeskind said, "reduce the overall density of the site to give the site room to breathe, make the memorial meaningful and eliminate sub-grade structural conflicts." The revisions also increase the amount of public space, he said, without the reducing commercial footage.


Many of the signature features of the plan, the 1776-foot spire attached to a 70-story office tower in the northwestern corner of the site, the Wedge of Light, and the exposed slurry wall remain the same, Libeskind said.

Since the choice of the Libeskind plan in February, rebuilding officials have been working to reconcile conflicts between commercial and memorial demands-the need to replace more than 10 million square feet of office space, restore 600,000 square feet of retail, provide new cultural facilities, restore and expand transportation
infrastructure, while leaving the footprints of the towers untouched for a memorial.

"We tried dozens and dozens of solutions," said Anthony Cracchiolo, director of priority capital programs for the Port Authority.

The current solutions rely upon using the site of 130 Liberty Street, the building that had been occupied by Deutsche Bank and remains covered in black cloth. One of the key uses of that site will be to route trucks directly off West Street into a security zone along Liberty Street, rather than beneath the memorial site as originally proposed.

The LMDC is currently in discussion with Deutsche Bank, which has said the building is unsafe and will need to be torn down. Two of the insurers of the building, however, have asserted the building can be renovated and used.

"The fact remains that we need to acquire the Deutsche Bank building," said Joseph Seymour, executive director of the Port Authority, "It's either going to be through eminent domain or through negotiations."

By shifting some of the office space into an off-site building, the two office towers along Church Street can

The revised plans for the footprints of the World Trade Center site are in part a response to victims' family members, like these demonstrating near the site on Sept. 10, who want to see the footprints free of new structures. Photo by Allan Tannenbaum
be made slimmer. Less massive buildings will increase the amount of light and air on the east side of the site, as well as making the office and retail space more marketable, Libeskind said. The juxtaposition of those buildings will also be altered to allow for more stores at street level, including the possibility of a single retail store of up to 140,000 square feet, according to Andrew Winters, LMDC Vice President and Director of Planning, Design and Development

Still to be determined is where hundreds of buses that will bring tourists to the site will be parked, a predominant concern of neighborhood residents. "We are still looking at several locations," said Winters. One option, shown at the presentation, is in Battery Park City at the northwest corner of West and Vesey streets. A final decision will be made in the next two to three months, according to Winters.

Another issue of contention has been the proposed burying of West Street, which has been opposed as too costly and disruptive by a vocal group of Battery Park City residents. Although the LMDC said no final decision has been made, a three-dimension model of the new plan presented on Sept.17 includes a West Street tunnel.

The Tribute in Light, as seen from Independence Plaza in Tribeca. Photo by Carl Glassman
 
"Before and after" overviews of plans for the World Trade Center site show some of the changes to the plans announced on Sept. 17, including the western portion of a new two-square block park on Liberty Street, between West and Church streets (at bottom of photo) and a taller, thinner office building (lower right corner) at Cedar and Church streets. Illustrations by the Lower Manhatttan Development Corporation