For Tribeca’s Screening, It’s Now Curtains

by Etta Sanders

Like a scene out of “The Last Picture Show.” Tribeca’s Screening Room has gone dark.

Late last month, the seven-year-old Screening Room closed, and the marquee, which had long announced Sunday screenings of “Breakfast at Tiffanys,” read, simply, “All Farewells Should Be Sudden.” A handwritten note on the locked door said, “Gone fishing for good (Probably). Thanks for all your support.”

Screening Room marquee announces the end of a seven-year run.

A sale of the the restaurant-theater, at Varick and Laight streets, is pending. The deal will give Tribeca a bigger restaurant, but it brings to an end the only movie house the neighborhood can call its own.

Word of the theater’s impending demise first leaked out at a meeting early last month of Community Board 1’s Tribeca Committee. The prospective buyers came for, and received, the board’s advisory approval for a transfer of the property’s liquor license.

Robert Schagrin, one of the three applicants, told the committee that he and his partners intend to expand the 152-seat restaurant and keep one of the two movie theaters, but only for private screenings. One partner, Michael Trenk, is director of Drew Nieporent’s Icon restaurant on East 39th Street.


The news came as a surprise to the community board members. “It was certainly a disappointment to me, and even more to my children, that the Screening Room was going out of business,” said Michael Connolly, who lives on North Moore Street. “It will be sorely missed.”

The small, independent theater opened in the summer of 1996, specializing in art films and documentaries. With its adjacent restaurant, it offered the complete date: dinner and a movie for a single price.

Co-owner Henry Hershkowitz declined to comment, but like other Downtown businesses, the Screening Room struggled after Sept. 11. In an article in Crain’s New York Business in June 2003, Hershkowitz said that competition from the Landmark Sunshine on Houston Street also hurt their business.

“When we opened seven years ago, there were less theaters Downtown,” he told Crain’s. “It’s always been difficult, but the Sunshine has made it much more difficult.”

A handwritten sign on the door says that the theater has gone fishing for good,

Hershkowitz, a former lawyer, and his partner Steven Kantor, a business-school graduate, were both 29 and disaffected from the corporate world when they opened the Screening Room.

Miriam Wysoker, who lives a few blocks from the theater, said she lovedhaving the Screening Room nearby and liked the movies they show. But she noticed that when she went in the afternoon or early evenings, there were few other customers. “ I can’t see how it could have stayed in business,” she said.

The Screening Room’s demise comes on the heels of the closing of five of the 16 screens in Battery Park City’s Regal Cinemas.