A Film from Center Ring of a Media Circus

by Carl Glassman

Until the terrorists struck, no event had so overtaken Tribeca as the deaths in July 1999 of John F. Kennedy, Jr., his wife Carolyn, and Carolyn’s sister Lauren Bessette. The disappearance of their small plane off Martha’s Vineyard provided few images for the picture-hungry press, and the gray, faceless building at 20 North Moore Street where the Kennedys lived quickly became a visual focal point–turned– spectacle.
Bill Brand and Ruth Hardinger in front of Hardinger’s--and the Kennedys'--building at 20 N. Moore Street, which became the focus of a media spectacle following their deaths in July 1999. Photo by Carl Glassman.

With a huge media corps camped across the street, mourners and curiosity seekers passed the building, day and night, for nearly two weeks. They came bearing flowers, letters, candles, photos, paintings and knickknacks, turning the front of the building into a mountainous shrine, and those who lived there into unwitting captives. As the crowds kept coming, the cameras kept rolling, their lenses fixed on 20 North Moore Street.

The glare of the spotlight shone brightest, literally, on the ground-floor apartment of Kennedy neighbors Ruth Hardinger and Michael Norton.

Hardinger, an artist and Tribeca real estate agent who has lived in the building since 1977, felt the need to create a work of some sort from her privileged position. Her medium is sculpture and drawing, but she wanted to make a film.

“It was such an intense experience, the feeling that we were trapped, and the horrible sadness of it all,” says Hardinger, who describes her relationship with the Kennedys as neighborly. “I had this urge to do something creative with it.”

A chance meeting on the street with her friend Bill Brand, a filmmaker and Franklin Street resident, evolved into a collaborative 40-minute documentary, shown last month at the Tribeca Film Festival, called “I’m a Pilot Like You.” (The title comes from one of many inscriptions to John F. Kennedy, Jr. left at the memorial.)

The film is less a documentary of the event than a personal glimpse of what it was like to be caught within it. Its pace matches the plodding movement of visitors strolling endlessly by, and extended shots of the spectacle on those hot summer nights induce a sense of claustrophobia that Hardinger herself must have felt. Even in front of the building, she seems almost lost on her own street.

The film turns the media/gawkers’ gaze back onto itself and gives viewers a kind of house-of-mirrors look at the bizarre scene. Brand’s camera peeks back at the news cameras recording the scene that we see Norton watching on TV upstairs and Hardinger viewing from the window. Brand calls it a “cycle of looking.”

“What became interesting to us was the way that our own experience, particularly Ruth’s experience, was

 
The scene, as viewed from Hardinger’s apartment. Photo by Bill Brand.
both part of and influenced by the spectacle. And that spectacle, in turn, was both created by and reflected in the media

The filmmakers said their intent was not to belittle those who came to pay their respects. “Emotions were very real, and people’s sentiments were very deep,” says Brand. Nevertheless, he has his most fun with some double-daters from Philadelphia who arrive by stretch limo to photograph themselves showing off at the shrine. From behind the camera, Brand asks one of the men why they came.

“For a guy to have $50 million and ride the subway, he’s a pretty down-to-earth guy, you know what I mean?” he replies. “That’s what I respect about him. You know what I mean?”

Hardinger was so put off by the experience that she could not pick up a camera for two years. And reminders never end. Camera-toting visitors still appear on their doorstep almost daily, she and Norton say.

“It’s really amazing to me,” says Norton, “that people get a kind of sustenance out of photographing a gray door and a doorbell of someone who has been dead for four years.”

Brand and Hardinger hope to give a public screening of the film next month. Further information will be posted at bboptics.com/pilot.html.