‘Getting Into Heaven’ Needs Divine Help

by Kelly Monaghan

The great thing about New York theater is that, no matter how convinced you are that you have seen the world’s worst play, given sufficient time you will eventually see one that tops it. Consider Polly Draper’s “Getting Into Heaven,” now at the Flea Theater on White Street.

Forty-something “badass rock star” Cat and her drummer Rose are two mommies to seven-year-old Danny, sired by Jed, the band’s soundman and an aspiring rapper. Now Jed is attempting to impregnate Cat so the couple can have a second child. Jed’s Mom, Crystal, a new-age Brit and supportive granny to this menage a trois, has a “phantom caller” to whom she pours out her innermost secrets.

Polly Draper (left), the playwright, as rock star Cat and Gretchen Egolf as her lover, Rose, in “Getting Into Heaven.”

Jed hates the way Danny calls him “Daddy,” but when Rose goes to admonish him on this point, Jed confesses his undying love, and they wind up having passionate sex. Crystal interrupts them and shares this gossip with her phantom caller, who turns out to be Cat, who has discovered that Crystal’s disembodied voice makes her purr.

On Halloween, Cat announces she’s pregnant by Jed, while Danny, who is dressed up as Supergirl, flies out a window to his death. Jed, now known as J. Dogg, wins a Grammy for “My Seed,” a rap tribute to Danny. Cat gives birth to Lily, but not before relapsing on smack, which prompts Rose to move in with Jed. Meanwhile, Crystal reveals to Jed that his real father is John Lennon, who had it off with Crystal on a floor in Bath after a psychic reading. We also learn that Rose was once the lover of Jed’s elder brother, who died while jumping out of a speeding car to retrieve his cocaine. Rose reconciles with Cat only to realize that Cat is once again using. She takes the baby and walks out. Distraught, Cat overdoses and dies.

This summary does Ms. Draper’s play a service. It is actually much worse than it sounds. What was she thinking? Was this supposed to be a hiply ironic comedy of modern manners? (You’d certainly need a heart of stone not to laugh aloud at the music video of “My Seed” that opens Act Two.) Or is it a cautionary tale for lesbian couples thinking of using a live sperm donor instead of a turkey baster? Or a pilot for a soap opera targeted at the burgeoning junkie-lesbian demographic? Ms. Draper’s TV roots seem to show through. Despite the not-for-television subject matter, the tone is oddly conventional, a sort of “Partridge Family” with four-letter words.

One can only hope that Ms. Draper will consider this vein mined and move on to more promising material. For despite a tendency to weak jokes and ludicrous melodrama, she writes characters that, while never quite believable, are eminently playable. Ms. Draper scores as the rock star, Gretchen Egolf is a fetching Rose, and James Badge Dale as the crossover white rapper is, well, “dope.”

Under Claire Lundberg’s heroic direction, Matthew Richard’s lighting, Fitz Patton’s sound and Michael Wolff’s original score give the show an edgy energy not readily apparent in the script.

In a truly embarrassing coda, Cat finds herself in heaven and is advised by Danny’s shade to plead her case to the audience, for the thoughts of the living are a crucial factor in gaining admission. For one ghastly moment, I was afraid we’d be asked to vote. Ms. Draper spared us that indignity, but I for one was ready to vote her in if only to put the play out of its misery.

“Getting Into Heaven” through Aug. 22 at the Flea Theater, 41 White St. 212-352-3101 or go to www.theatermania.com. $25.